Sunlit living room in a small Maine cottage, with a linen sofa, teal cushion, pine floors and a wood stove beside a window overlooking late-autumn trees.

What Surry's Housing Numbers Say About the Homes Hardest to Find

On the evening of September 2, the walls of the Blue Hill Town Hall auditorium held drawings of houses that don't exist yet. One was a three-bedroom of about 1,160 square feet that could stand alone or be mirrored into a duplex. Another was a four-unit building drawn as a large farmhouse, the kind of shape that already sits along the roads between Surry and Blue Hill. The Penobscot Bay Press reported that CommunityScale planner Kate Burch told the room there is "a huge need for starter homes for sale," which she described as two- and three-bedroom houses priced below $400,000.

Most buyers looking at Surry start with the shorefront on Newbury Neck and Morgan Bay. The peninsula's own housing study points somewhere else. In Surry, the home that is hardest to find is the small one under $400,000 that a person can live in all year. The study's dashboard ranks entry-level ownership among the five deepest housing needs on the peninsula.

Where Surry's price sits on the peninsula

That study is called Housing Opportunities on the Peninsula, or HOOP. It is a collaboration of 10 towns: Blue Hill, Brooklin, Brooksville, Castine, Deer Isle, Orland, Penobscot, Sedgwick, Stonington and Surry. It is funded by a state Municipal Housing Grant and led by members from each town, working with the Hancock County Regional Planning Commission, CommunityScale, Neighbor Architects and Levine Planning Strategies. The project's public dashboard at hoopmaine.org puts a typical-home figure on each member town. These are modeled values, not closed-sale medians, but they rank the towns on the same scale.

As of September 2026, HOOP puts Surry's typical home at $430,530. That is a little above the peninsula-wide figure of $416,161.

Town HOOP typical home, Sept. 2026 Affordable at local median income
Blue Hill $500,370 $393,424
Brooklin $454,723 $324,786
Surry $430,530 $330,101
Sedgwick $412,818 $311,616
Penobscot $338,600 $282,468
Orland $288,945 $337,400
Blue Hill Peninsula $416,161 $322,984

For a buyer, the important line is the gap. A Surry household earning the town's median income of $79,959 can afford about $330,101, which leaves it $100,430 short of the typical home on the September 2026 figures. Buying that typical house takes an income of about $104,285. Surry costs less than Blue Hill and noticeably more than Orland, and its typical home already sits above the $400,000 line Burch used to define a starter home. That means a two- or three-bedroom house below that line is, by definition, a below-typical house in Surry. Below-typical houses are the ones more buyers can stretch to reach.

A town turning more year-round

The second set of HOOP numbers shows how the town is being used. HOOP groups Surry and Blue Hill into one submarket. Between 2019 and 2024, seasonally vacant homes there fell 15 percent, and the number of people working from home rose 279 percent. Fewer houses sitting empty for part of the year and many more residents working from home both point to the same thing: more of the housing in this part of the peninsula is being used as primary homes.

Short-term rentals point the same way. Using AirDNA data from 2021 to 2024, drawn from the 2025 Hancock County Housing Needs Assessment, HOOP reports that 8.3 percent of homes in the Surry and Blue Hill submarket were used as short-term rentals. The same table shows 10.1 percent in Ellsworth, 14.5 percent in Mount Desert, 21.7 percent in Bar Harbor and 21.8 percent in Southwest Harbor.

Those trends have not made the small house easier to buy. HOOP lists entry and workforce ownership, two- and three-bedroom homes at $240,000 to $395,000, as "the hardest home to buy here," and says that homes that free up "get bought as second homes, so they rarely reach local buyers." Taken together, the dashboard shows two kinds of demand reaching the same modest houses. More households are living on the peninsula year-round and working from home, while the small homes that come up for sale still draw second-home buyers. A year-round buyer in Surry faces both kinds of competition.

Why the small house is the bottleneck

On the supply side, the peninsula is building far below what HOOP says it needs. The dashboard counts 137 building permits across the peninsula in the previous five years. Its model calls for 712 new units from 2026 to 2031, or about 142 a year. As reported in the Penobscot Bay Press, steering committee member George Borowsky estimated the area needs 700 to 1,000 more units over the next five years, "at least six times" what the previous five produced.

The rental market adds pressure on ownership. HOOP puts peninsula rental vacancy at 1.4 percent, compared with what it calls a minimum stable target of 7.4 percent. With so few rentals open, people who would otherwise rent while they look are more likely to try to buy, and the price range they try to buy in is the starter-home range.

The shortage reaches older residents too. Burch said the 10-town area has "a real lack of smaller rental or ownership units" for seniors who want to leave a larger house without leaving their community. HOOP's dashboard describes the senior and downsizer home, one or two bedrooms on a single level, as "the unlock," because older owners won't leave a big house without a single-level one to move into, and "each one built frees up a family home."

Surry's own committees are working on this. A March 2026 notice on the Town of Surry news page says the Surry Economic and Community Development Committee is "currently exploring 55+ housing and other development activities which broaden Surry's tax base," in the words of chair Tom Welgoss. The same notice says the committee helped other peninsula towns secure the $175,000 no-match grant behind the study, and that its members include Borowsky.

What the county numbers add

The Hancock County figures from the Maine Association of Realtors fit the same picture. For August through October 2026, the association's November 12 report counts 226 single-family sales in the county, 8.13 percent fewer than in the same months of 2025, while the median sale price rose 10.99 percent to $505,000. The prior month's report put the July through September 2026 county median at $527,962, up 18.38 percent from a year earlier.

Fewer sales at a higher median means the mix of homes that sold this fall leaned toward the expensive end. The county median is now well above Surry's typical home, which is above the starter line. Each step down that ladder covers fewer homes.

The statewide market has given buyers some room. The Bangor Daily News reported on October 30 that more Maine sellers are accepting offers below asking. Laurie Smallidge of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate The Masiello Group told the paper that buyers can be selective and negotiate favorable terms, and that the pandemic-era rush of multiple offers is over. The same article noted that sellers often want to close before winter rather than heat two houses. That is a statewide reading. In Surry, the room to negotiate is likely to be widest on larger and pricier listings, and narrowest on the small year-round house the study identifies as scarce.

What December brings

HOOP's final product, a Housing Development Toolkit, is scheduled for December 2026. It will cover case studies for missing-middle housing along with construction, infrastructure, financing and regulatory strategies. At the September meeting, MIT's Jeff Levine discussed Affordable Housing Tax Increment Financing as one tool towns are considering. According to the Penobscot Bay Press, a September slide listed eight possible roles for HOOP as a longer-term regional group, from planning to developing.

None of this adds houses to the market this winter. Even at HOOP's target pace of 142 units a year spread across 10 towns, Surry's share of new small homes would arrive gradually. A buyer shopping in Surry over the next year is shopping the existing stock.

Two practical details help with that search. The committee's March notice says it built a searchable GIS database of every land parcel in town, after a two-year effort to update 15 years of parcel data. That is a useful starting point for anyone weighing an older house that needs work against a lot to build on. For land, the site itself often sets the real cost before the asking price does, which our post on how well and septic set prices on the Blue Hill Peninsula covers. The second detail is town character. Surry has trademarked the tagline "Gateway to the Blue Hill Peninsula," and the location fits it: Ellsworth's services are close by, and the rest of the Blue Hill Peninsula is down the road.

If you are looking in Surry for a two- or three-bedroom house you can live in all year, the Acadia Realty Team is glad to talk through the listings near the $400,000 line before winter. Brenda Shelton works with first-time and second-home buyers. If you own a smaller home on the peninsula, a home valuation will show you where it sits on HOOP's price ladder. Let's Connect.

WORK WITH STEVE

Steve listens carefully to his client's needs and does everything in his power to bring buyers and sellers together for a mutually satisfying real estate experience.

Follow Us on Instagram