A Bar Harbor listing can show years of weekly bookings, a strong summer calendar and a tidy income history. None of that comes with the deed. Under the town's Land Use Ordinance, a short-term rental registration cannot be transferred. If a non-owner-occupied rental, which the town calls a VR-2, sells partway through the registration year, the seller's registration covers that unit only until the next May 31. A buyer closing this month would have rental rights through May 31, 2027. After that, the buyer applies as a brand-new VR-2 applicant in a capped program that has been over its limit since the cap was created.
So in Bar Harbor, the rental history in a listing belongs to a registration that ends with the seller's ownership. Every closing on a legacy VR-2 takes one registration out of the town's count for good. Each sale also moves the town toward a housing goal it has struggled to reach any other way.
The Rule, in the Ordinance's Own Words
The relevant language is in § 125-69Y of the Bar Harbor Land Use Ordinance. Two sentences carry the rule:
"If there is a change of ownership mid-term, the registration remains valid for the dwelling unit, or part thereof, to which it was issued until it expires on the following May 31."
"Transfer of registration is prohibited. The transfer of any short-term rental registration is expressly prohibited."
The same section caps VR-2 registrations townwide at 9% of Bar Harbor's total dwelling units. The Assessor sets that unit count at the start of each calendar year, so the cap itself can change from year to year. Voters approved the framework 1,260 to 840 in November 2021. Rentals that already existed could keep operating as long as they passed inspections and renewed on time, which put the town over its own cap from day one.
In November 2025 the Town Council rewrote the separate Short-Term Rental Registration chapter, Chapter 174. That rewrite took effect December 18, 2025, and it still points back to the Land Use Ordinance for the term, cap and transfer rules. The rule against transferring a registration is current law.
Why the Waitlist Hasn't Moved
A buyer whose inherited registration runs out has to apply, pay the fee and join the VR-2 waitlist kept by the Code Enforcement Officer. When a slot opens, the applicant at the top has 120 days to get registered before the slot goes to the next person. Slots only open when the number of VR-2s falls below the cap. Here is how far above it the town has been:
| Year | Registered VR-2s | 9% cap | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | 485 | 307 | Bar Harbor Story, Sept. 2023 |
| 2024 | 470 | Not reported | Bar Harbor Story, Aug. 2024 |
| 2025 | 420 | About 296 | Mount Desert Islander |
The 2025 figures are the most recent published. We could not find a count from after the May 31, 2026 renewal deadline. Even so, the gap in the 2025 numbers is wide. About 125 VR-2s would have to disappear before a single waitlist slot opens. In 2023, 36 properties were already waiting.
How registrations drop out matters. According to the Mount Desert Islander, the largest single piece of the drop from 470 to 420 was one large property owner who chose not to re-register 20 units, Code Enforcement Officer Mike Gurtler said. Other owners decided to stop renting or missed the deadline. Sales work the same way, just more slowly and steadily. Each closing on a VR-2 is one more registration that won't be renewed, and the cap means it won't be reissued to anyone while the count stays above the limit.
Council Chair Val Peacock described the pace plainly in the same Islander article: "We knew that it was going to be a long game before we'd actually be able to reduce the number of short-term rentals." She also pointed to the other half of the equation, which is adding housing units to the denominator.
VR-2s are concentrated in a few places. In the Islander's latest snapshot, the Downtown Residential district had 121, the Shoreland Limited Residential district had 64, and Downtown Village II had 44. In those districts, listings are most likely to come with rental history, so the transfer rule comes up most often there.
What Counts as a "Transfer"
The ordinance defines a transfer by paperwork. Any conveyance shown on a Maine Real Estate Transfer Tax Declaration counts. So does a conveyance of a controlling interest in an entity, shown on a Maine Controlling Interest Transfer Declaration. Owning a rental through an LLC doesn't get around the rule when control of the LLC changes hands.
The rule has also caught changes that weren't sales. In 2023, then-Code Enforcement Officer Angela Chamberlain said deed changes could void registrations, according to Bar Harbor Story. Her examples were a deed change removing a co-owner and a co-owner moving an interest into a trust. Some of those registrations were voided. Two of the properties qualified as owner-occupied rentals instead. That year, one VR-2 renewal was denied specifically because the property had changed hands.
The May 31 Cliff, Step by Step
For a buyer closing on a registered VR-2 in October 2026, the timeline looks like this:
- At closing, the seller's registration stays valid for that specific unit.
- On May 31, 2027, it expires. Because transfers are prohibited, the new owner can't renew it.
- To keep renting as a VR-2, the buyer submits a complete new application and fee and joins the waitlist.
- If a slot opens, the buyer has 120 days to get registered. Every registration also requires a life-safety inspection at the start and again every three years.
May 31 is a hard deadline for current owners as well. A registration that isn't renewed by that date expires and can't be renewed. The owner then has to apply from scratch as a new registrant. The town enforces the program. In February 2026, according to Bar Harbor Story, an Ellsworth District Court default judgment awarded the town $47,700 in fines and penalties over an unregistered short-term rental.
The Owner-Occupied Option Got Narrower in 2025
The other category, VR-1, has no cap. It's built for people who live in Bar Harbor. To qualify, the property or another dwelling unit on the same lot has to be the owner's primary residence. A single property ID can hold at most two VR-1 registrations. Minimum stays also differ: two nights for a VR-1 and four nights for a VR-2.
The November 2025 rewrite tightened how residence is proven. A VR-1 applicant must own the property, document it as their primary residence, attest to living there more than 183 days a year and submit at least three items from a list of seven documents. No individual can be the primary resident on more than one VR-1. The code allows limited exceptions when an additional ownership interest comes from a parent, spouse or legal guardian for estate planning, inheritance or caregiving. The Mount Desert Islander reported that the Council adopted the amended version 5-0-2, with Earl Brechlin and Steve Boucher abstaining. Language that would have required consent to an interior inspection was dropped.
VR-1 registrations had been rising. The same Islander snapshot counted 172 as of June 1, up from 143 at that point in 2024. Unlike VR-2s, VR-1s have no single annual deadline, so the count is harder to pin down. A buyer who plans to live in the home has a workable route to short-term rental income. A buyer who plans to rent the whole property to visitors goes to the back of a line that hasn't moved.
How This Changes the Math on Both Sides of the Table
For sellers, a rental income history is accurate. It shows what the property earned under the seller's registration. Once the buyer's grace period ends, the property's future income depends on how the buyer will use it: as a primary residence with a VR-1, as a long-term rental, as a second home, or as a VR-2 applicant waiting for a slot. The MDI rental property overview on our site gives broader context on island rentals. Bar Harbor's transfer rule is the detail that most changes a buyer's numbers inside town lines.
For buyers, the rule turns several things into practical questions before an offer:
- Does the property hold a VR-1 or a VR-2 registration, and when did it last renew?
- Would the planned use qualify for a VR-1 under the 2025 residence rules?
- If the plan depends on a VR-2, what does the property pencil out to as a long-term rental or personal-use home, given that a new registration isn't guaranteed?
- Will the closing involve a trust, a co-owner change or an LLC whose controlling interest is changing?
These are questions about how the ordinance applies. Code Enforcement and the buyer's own attorney can answer them for a specific property.
Quick Answers
Can a buyer keep renting through the summer after closing? If the property has a valid registration at closing, it stays in effect for that unit until the following May 31.
Does buying through an LLC avoid the rule? A conveyance of a controlling interest in an entity, shown on a Maine Controlling Interest Transfer Declaration, counts as a transfer.
Will the November 3, 2026 town meeting change any of this? The warrant has a school reorganization question and a land-use amendment that aligns local definitions with state housing law. Neither is listed as a change to the vacation rental cap.
If you own a registered VR-2 in Bar Harbor, or you're weighing an offer on one, the registration status affects the price as much as the condition and the view. Steve, Josh and the rest of Acadia Realty Team can help you see how a property holds up once its rental registration ends. You can also start with a home valuation. Let's Connect.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.